olifer
Sophomore Member
Posts: 191 
|
Post by olifer on Apr 28, 2024 5:50:41 GMT -6
Hiring a head coach to run a successful D1 basketball program requires a lot more thought than many of us realize.
Just because someone appears to be successful as an assistant coach, doesn’t guarantee that they’ll make a good head coach. Most assistants aren’t tasked with leadership and management duties which is a big part of being a head coach, especially at this level.
Dawn and Amy both possessed strong leadership skills, whereas we really didn’t get to see as much of that with Kayla. She’s either still developing those skills, or may not be strong in that area. Regardless, that component is a pretty big deal here.
A company that I worked at some 30 years ago took its top salesperson and moved him into a management position because he deserved the promotion. The problem was that while he could sell snow to an Eskimo, he sucked at being a leader so the company lost its best sales guy and was now being led by a poor manager. No one benefited from that promotion.
In my opinion, we need a strong proven leader, not just a good coach.
|
|
|
|
Post by kiyoat on Apr 28, 2024 7:14:01 GMT -6
…The problem was that while he could sell snow to an Eskimo, he sucked at being a leader so the company lost its best sales guy and was now being led by a poor manager. No one benefited from that promotion. In my opinion, we need a strong proven leader, not just a good coach. The Peter Principle, basically. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_principle |
|
dbyote
Senior Member
Posts: 654
|
Post by dbyote on Apr 28, 2024 7:49:19 GMT -6
Let’s be real most of us think we are very important! There are going to be different opinions on every candidate. From what I can see Jewett checks a lot of boxes: Experience, can recruit, staying power, relatable, and motivates. So unless there is something I’m glaringly missing I’m not seeing were the disdain for him is coming from other than personal opinion/preference which is totally your prerogative. I just think that, given his age, someone would have already seen those qualities (if they were there) and given him the opportunity to run a program. There aren't many 50 something diamonds in the rough. I think we'd be settling for someone who would stay long term instead of shooting for the stars. I certainly understand the strategy, but it isn't the direction I would go. |
|
90yote
Senior Member
Posts: 657
|
Post by 90yote on Apr 28, 2024 8:02:35 GMT -6
Let’s be real most of us think we are very important! There are going to be different opinions on every candidate. From what I can see Jewett checks a lot of boxes: Experience, can recruit, staying power, relatable, and motivates. So unless there is something I’m glaringly missing I’m not seeing were the disdain for him is coming from other than personal opinion/preference which is totally your prerogative. I just think that, given his age, someone would have already seen those qualities (if they were there) and given him the opportunity to run a program. There aren't many 50 something diamonds in the rough. I think we'd be settling for someone who would stay long term instead of shooting for the stars. I certainly understand the strategy, but it isn't the direction I would go. I don't have a strong opinion on this, but it's certainly possible that summary is correct, but you (as well as I) are commenting as an outsider. It's also possible that when he was younger (with young kids) that he didn't want to move out of state to pursue head coaching jobs and it's also fair to say he had a pretty good gig in Brookings. We don't know any of the backstory here, so perhaps he is interested in this job, and that may or may not have been influenced by his interim role this season. I don't think he should be downgraded for the reason stated above (or that someone on this message board threatens dropping their season tickets 😂). I also don't think he should be hired because major boosters are trying to influence it. Assume you agree there. |
|
|
|
Post by yoteforever on Apr 28, 2024 8:04:31 GMT -6
I don’t know Coach Jewett at all. I’m sure he’s one heck of a nice guy. I’m also sure the girls would support that hire as it would be a “safe” pick because they are comfortable with him. I have ZERO clue if he’s capable of succeeding as a head coach or not. I’m reasonably certain he will at minimum be on the short list.
One thing I can 100% guaranty you about is AD Schemmel being influenced by boosters and those close to the program. I’m dead sure he’d listen to those that he respects, but ultimately he’s going to be the one that decides. In (4) months he’s proven he’s not afraid to make hard decisions.
I would bet the consulting firm has a long list of qualified candidates. We will get a coach that passes the sniff test for sure. It might be Coach Jewett, it might be a sitting head coach at a very successful smaller school like the young lady at Minnesota State, or it could be an associate head coach of a Power 5 school that is ready to be a head coach.
There are “I told you so” risks with each hire I listed above. If it’s Mike, and he is less than spectacular, the boo birds come out of the closet saying “I told you so”. If it’s someone like the young lady at Minnesota State and they aren’t hugely successful, then the same group comes out of the closet saying they couldn’t succeed at the next level. If it’s the assistant coach, like Coach Jeske as some suggested off Dawns staff or a coach like that, and they don’t succeed the same group comes out saying never hire a coach that doesn’t have a head coaching track record.
Schemmel will hire one heck of a coach. The other side of success is supporting that program. It isn’t free
We have turned the corner in my opinion on the direction we’re going as a department. But we’re only 1-2 steps in on where we have to be. My advice is sit back and enjoy this process. This is Jon’s first major sport hire. He deserves our support. Whoever he chooses, lets back him and the new coach with all you have.
|
|
|
|
Post by marco on Apr 28, 2024 9:00:33 GMT -6
He said in Sioux Falls we are following behind in money his talk got us an extra 200,000 . There is money out there to run a good program. I want Mike and give a chunk to athletics but I will trust who he picks. But I am sure he hears from many big supporters . Hope next week an announcement will come. One more thing this job is a great place to be for a young coach we have 2 ex coaches in the big ten
|
|
dbyote
Senior Member
Posts: 654
|
Post by dbyote on Apr 28, 2024 9:47:47 GMT -6
I just think that, given his age, someone would have already seen those qualities (if they were there) and given him the opportunity to run a program. There aren't many 50 something diamonds in the rough. I think we'd be settling for someone who would stay long term instead of shooting for the stars. I certainly understand the strategy, but it isn't the direction I would go. I don't have a strong opinion on this, but it's certainly possible that summary is correct, but you (as well as I) are commenting as an outsider. It's also possible that when he was younger (with young kids) that he didn't want to move out of state to pursue head coaching jobs and it's also fair to say he had a pretty good gig in Brookings. We don't know any of the backstory here, so perhaps he is interested in this job, and that may or may not have been influenced by his interim role this season. I don't think he should be downgraded for the reason stated above (or that someone on this message board threatens dropping their season tickets 😂). I also don't think he should be hired because major boosters are trying to influence it. Assume you agree there. I love having conversations with reasonable people. My opinion shouldn't really matter because I'll never have the means to have influence but the choice will affect whether I ever travel 6 hours to see a game. I used to get down there s couple times a year for basketball games. I have zero desire to go watch either team right now. Who would have thought that football would be the best product we have? |
|
90yote
Senior Member
Posts: 657
|
Post by 90yote on Apr 28, 2024 9:52:05 GMT -6
I don't have a strong opinion on this, but it's certainly possible that summary is correct, but you (as well as I) are commenting as an outsider. It's also possible that when he was younger (with young kids) that he didn't want to move out of state to pursue head coaching jobs and it's also fair to say he had a pretty good gig in Brookings. We don't know any of the backstory here, so perhaps he is interested in this job, and that may or may not have been influenced by his interim role this season. I don't think he should be downgraded for the reason stated above (or that someone on this message board threatens dropping their season tickets 😂). I also don't think he should be hired because major boosters are trying to influence it. Assume you agree there. I love having conversations with reasonable people. My opinion shouldn't really matter because I'll never have the means to have influence but the choice will affect whether I ever travel 6 hours to see a game. I used to get down there s couple times a year for basketball games. I have zero desire to go watch either team right now. Who would have thought that football would be the best product we have? Yes, we are a football school now! Well, I hope you have reason to get back for basketball in the near future! |
|
|
|
Post by coyotefan74 on Apr 28, 2024 11:20:18 GMT -6
And Volleyball, don’t forget them.
|
|
|
|
Post by kiyoat on Apr 29, 2024 7:50:40 GMT -6
Just a small piece of information I've heard (3rd hand, but reputable source)... is that at least some (if not all) the players really want to play for Coach Jewitt, and would be happy if he was named the HC. This isn't a newsflash, or anything. Just wanted to share it as something that is likely true and substantiated (not speculation). I have also heard that Demers and Holmes may have stayed if they had known there was going to be a coaching change, and if Mike was still here.
Of course, none of this means that Mike is the best candidate for the job. That's for the AD to determine. I just wanted to share what I have learned.
I do wish I knew where some of the animosity towards Mike from some of the fans on here is coming from, though. I've also seen some cryptic posts on social media denigrating him and his "coaching history", saying he's a creep, or something like that. I can't help but think that might be some overzealous State fans that did not like him coaching in Vermillion? Or people wondering why he would have left AJ's staff in the first place, and someone came up with a (false) narrative? If there were any personal issues with him similar to what is being said by hecklers, there's no way he would have been hired by the Brookings School District, or USD for that matter. There is a vetting process.
I'm just chalking it up to idiot fans who think they know more than they do. I'll take the opinions of his players over random anonymous hecklers/trolls, who don't cite anything specific.
|
|
|
|
Post by marco on Apr 29, 2024 10:30:48 GMT -6
I heard the same thing that players like Mike from a good source. The AD will take this in account and maybe he has a name he likes. I hope we get it done soon . We need to be out recruiting and have a spot for another portal player.
|
|
|
|
Post by yotenation on Apr 29, 2024 10:40:36 GMT -6
I heard the same thing that players like Mike from a good source. The AD will take this in account and maybe he has a name he likes. I hope we get it done soon . We need to be out recruiting and have a spot for another portal player. The fact that the players like Jewett is encouraging and should absolutely be taken into account. However, it is only one factor. The players don't make the decision, nor should they. I'd be fine with Jewett but we absolutely should be conducting a thorough search to identify the best coach and fit. If it's Jewett, great. If not, fine. But you're right. At this stage there is a need to move with some urgency. |
|
|
|
Post by oldhare on Apr 29, 2024 12:24:05 GMT -6
Mike Jewett is a great guy. He did a great job for the Jackrabbits as associate head coach and the Brookings School District as the activities director. Most of the people that know Mike(& his family) will wish him the best wherever he lands. He has always worked well with young people in a positive direction. Mike's brief stint as AD also demonstrated his leadership in the community. I am not certain what he may have done in Vermillion to create animosity.
|
|
|
|
Post by yoteforever on Apr 29, 2024 12:44:03 GMT -6
He hasn’t done a darn thing. Some people aren’t ever happy.
|
|
|
|
Post by elcoyote on Apr 29, 2024 12:59:37 GMT -6
Mike Jewett is a great guy. He did a great job for the Jackrabbits as associate head coach and the Brookings School District as the activities director. Most of the people that know Mike(& his family) will wish him the best wherever he lands. He has always worked well with young people in a positive direction. Mike's brief stint as AD also demonstrated his leadership in the community. I am not certain what he may have done in Vermillion to create animosity. Absolutely nothing, in fact just the opposite. Everything you say is right on the button. I've never heard a negative thing about him in Vermillion. Only naysayer I know of is one idiot poster on this message board who basically bashes everybody and everything (the spawn of coyote fan). |
|
